Monday, January 30, 2012

James Belich, Matthew Wright, war comics and big nouns...


At the moment I am trying to catch up on background reading. I need to get a good sense of the overall dynamic and development of what were once called 'The Maori Wars', then became 'The New Zealand Wars', then they became 'the Land Wars'. 

The instability of title points to a problem of 'ownership'. Whose wars were they? Are they? Who caused them and who, even, fought them (given that kaupapa or 'friendlies' or 'Queenites' were Maori who actually fought alongside the 'imperial' or 'local' or 'Pakeha' sides...)

The wars are both terribly complex (what happened when) and terribly simple (what it was about.)

(What it was about: land, survival, a place to stand, a place to live - for both tangata whenua and migrants.)

I look at 'Contested Ground/ Te Whenua I Tohea' (The Taranaki Wars 1860-1881) and Matthew Wright's 'Two People, One Land- the New Zealand Wars' and feel exhausted by the internecine intricacy of the wars. (Both books are excellent, by the way.) 

I sense that the gusto and slightly nerdy passion which James Belich and Matthew Wright bring to their studies could be traced back to a boy's love of war comics. I never liked war comics, finding their all-male universe uninteresting. Valour, danger, male feats, guns, weaponry mean very little to me - have almost no resonance. So when I sit down and try and make sense of where Kereopa Te Rau fits in, within the schema of the 1860s wars, I become lost in a snowstorm of detail - of words, of battles, of poorly understood Maori names. 

Will I ever understand? 






.....

Here's something that cheered me up.

'The pursuit of scholarly rigor too easily leads historians to erase any signs of imagination from their work. What is the historical imagination? It's the ability to see small and think big. Just thinking big leads you to Spenglerian melodrama and fantasy; just seeing small makes you miss history altogether while seeming to study it…….History helps us to understand reality by disassembling the big nouns into the small acts that make them up.' Adam Gopnik - the New Yorker, January 16, 2012.

'Disassembling the big nouns into small acts' makes sense to me. 

(Illustration c/- http://pocketwarcomics.blogspot.com/)

9 comments:

  1. It seems that anybody hopes to gucci replica own a appealing aerial beautiful handbag. We can generally see the appearance accessories arise in appearance magazines and appearance shows in the television. We will acquisition that the role of appearance artist handbags is acceptable added and added important in our circadian life. Top designers aswell accumulate their absorption on designing altered sizes, colors, shapes and materials. There are lots of acclaimed brands in the backpack market. Thus, the chanel replica antagonism a part of the acclaimed brands is actual nervous. There are assorted beautiful handbags for every accessible occasions. If you wish to appear black occasions, you can accept claws to bout your style. In day time, you can backpack bung aback accoutrements for yourself. If you were a business woman, you can acquirement structured handbags to brace able-bodied with you. In a word, there are abounding altered styles to accommodated appearance lovers' demands to appear altered occasions. Is it all-important for trendsetters to absorb accoutrements of hundreds of dollars on a backpack or a faddy bag? I anticipate that altered bodies accept altered answers. If you are liveing in the amphitheater of the affluent who consistently acquirement big-ticket goods, it agency that you accept the adeptness to prada belts allow the affluence things. Thus, I anticipate that it is actual all-important for you to pay hundreds of dollars for a admirable purse. Or conceivably you are just a appearance adeptness adult with accomplished taste. Today, admirable accept bags, appearance handbags, chichi wallets, artist purses, accidental backpacks, aerial black purses, briefcases and totes are all fabricated by designers. Searching online, you will acquisition that there are abounding online food accessible to action a huge accumulating of assorted artist handbags to the trendsetters. There are amaranthine pages for you to louis vuitton replica browse slowly.

    ReplyDelete
  2. which produce half handbagreplica a million pieces a year.”Come next month’s Baselworld fair, Mr. Linca will find plenty of Rolex Daytona kindred spirits. On March 22, Mr. Modig, the Replica handbags journalist, will hold a party for 10 independent brands at a former brewery that doubles as a club and Replica Watches a creative space for local artists. “These brands don’t have the financial muscle to Replica watches UK do anything on their own,” he said. “Half of them are somewhere.

    ReplyDelete
  3. The outside spine and covers will also need to be closely examined. After the comic is examined in this way, the reader can then begin to consider an overall grade for the book. Haunted gotham

    ReplyDelete