Sunday, September 19, 2010

A picture with depth

At the cemetery there is a silent kind of battle going on. This seems strange, I know. But for over a decade a group of elderly men have made it their task to keep the historic Napier Hill cemetery free of weeds and generally tidy.

This is no small task, as the cemetery cascades down a steep hill side and is peopled by giant gum trees which continually shed bark. In high storms, entire branches wham down and crack across sepulchres.

The odd bit of chemical poison doesn’t go amiss in keeping the cemetery generally ‘neat and tidy’ as a Hamilton motel garden in the 1970s.

A new group, of which I am a part, is now replanting the cemetery in flowers and plants highly valued by the early colonials - scented roses, bulbs.

The old chaps do not like this. They regard roses as nuisances. When I won the CLL Award - in a high state of excitment - I planted a Madame Alfred Barbiere climbing rose in a plot immediately behind Colenso’s grave.

I did not realise I was throwing down a challenge.

A few months later I arrived to find the rose hacked back.

The battle is about aesthetics, but also about control.

The thing which interests me is how these intersect.

Lately I have been reading an essay Colenso wrote about the ferns on Scinde Island. Scinde Island is the Victorian name for the Hill in Napier. Everyone local calls it The Hill. I have never heard anyone call it Scinde Island. Its Maori name is Mataruahoe.

One of the fascinating things about reading Colenso is that he is a master of the shaggy dog tale. He always diverts from the main subject - a botanical naming of the ferns on the Hill in this case. Instead he introduces his historical memories of the Hill. How he found it as one of the very early colonials to experience its wairua or spirit.

So we find that in its early state it was exceedingly barren - a ‘high,dry and isolated islet-like limestone mound, destitute of fresh water’ - but in the Southern part of the island there were some beautiful stands of karaka trees. ‘I think that grove was orginally a tabooed spot (probably a burial-place) of the old aborigines, who formerly dwelt there.’ Cormorants nested there. ‘It was both a pleasing and a curious sight to see them tending assiduously to their young in the breeding season, the white breasts and bellies of the parent-birds contrasting so strongly with the dense dark green foliage of the trees.

This grove of trees was quickly cut down by the imperial army when it arrived in Napier in February 1858. They did this for ‘small poles, for rude fencing and for tents.’ Other trees on the Hill were similarly felled, including the Ngaio trees ‘picturesquely fringing and overhanging the high water I have known Natives to frequently make fast their canoes, and, in the summer season, to bivouac under their shade. No Maori of the olden time would have cut down one of those ancient and useful trees! and, when the whites did so, they complained bitterly against it.’

In 1858, local Maori rangitira were fighting among themselves for supremacy. At the heart of these uneasy, violent disputes was a concern about land - the quick selling of land, who should sell the land, and what you should sell the land for.

The small European population huddled round the bottom of the hill was worried about the implications of these disputes. Even though the battles were entirely Maori.

Enter: the imperial army. Exit: the beautiful glossy green karaka trees.

It is only too easy to parallel pakeha presence with deforestation. Unfortunately substantial tracts of Hawke’s Bay/Heretaunga had already been deforested by the Maori custom of burning back. This occured right around coastal New Zealand. So it is a more complex picture than you might think. You also get the interesting colonial individual, like William Colenso who carefully noted the types of ferns and native plantings which existed on the Hill.

This was a pakeha virtue, you could say. Some would say that it was all part of a pakeha desire to attach New Zealand horticulturally to Britain - to make it some kind of outpost. A botanical colony, if you will.

On the other hand, this careful notation means this memory lingers and is of inestimable value for the future.

Nothing is quite as straight forward as polemicists - either pakeha racists or Maori racists - would like to make out. The interplay between the two cultures was subtle, of varying degrees of intensity and pockets of individualism always stood out.

But back to the dispute in the cemetery. The argument is about aesthetics, but in a larger sense, about an idea of space or place. We, perhaps nostalgically, would like to reintroduce plants which evoke memory for the colonials buried there.

The old chaps like to keep things shipshape and tidy. At the moment it is unresolved.

Every so often something we plant just goes missing.

But at the moment the flag irises I planted are flowering, a magnificent mauve-purple.

I would like to see if we can reintroduce into the cemetery some of the ferns Colenso talks about. But I would also like to continue with the roses.

(I realise many pakeha purists would insist only on native plantings, that is, native re-plantings. They can't see this is as false as a carpet-bedding. That is, both are equal fabrications of place.)

This kind of complexity is what I like - a mixture of things.

A jumble of names.

A picture with depth.


  1. This comment has been removed by the author.

  2. There are two variations to the omega replica Formula 1 watch collection, the alarm and automatic. The automated adaptation is abundant added analytic priced and downgraded from the alarm version, but still a acceptable sports watch. The automated adaptation is bass down with a argent punch and argent sub-dials. The cast name is placed craftily beneath the 12 o'clock mark and the Formula 1 logo placed just aloft the 6 o'clock mark. The alarm Tag Heuer replica watch has a white or atramentous sub dials, agnate to the cartier replica automated version. However, it is the additional adverse that stands out from a lot of watches. It actualization a aggregate of three colors that anniversary covers 20 seconds. It is the ablaze colors that accompany the watch to activity while still advancement a able and admirable design. Not alone is it the absolute timing that makes Tag Heuer's watches so accepted amidst assorted antic events, but aswell the rolex replica admirable adventurous look. It's simple and chichi at the aforementioned time, with abounding of the watches accepting chronographs. Although there are watches in abounding altered sports, it is the watches plan with motor antagonism that has sparked a Formula 1 replica watch accumulating of its own. The Tag Heuer replica watch was initially alien in 1986, with abounding of the a lot of replica watches uk arresting racers antic the watch. There are several actualization that accomplish this accumulating angle out from added watches, but it is the ablaze colors that bolt the eye first. It uses a chancy but different architecture arrangement by analogous the punch blush with the accents put on the replica watches alfresco of the case.

  3. will be available handbagreplica in June, the price will start from $ US995. The following figure, golden Frederique Constant model shows Rolex Daytona retail trout $ US1295.Before, we too deeply awkwardly Replica Watches Smartwatches which was named, we have defined a very loosely category “. MMT of smart Replica watches UK ” is there is a need to clarify what you mean, Samsung and Apple equipment that can be included from Replica handbags the calculator Casio wrist of 80s-style.


  4. Rolex Air King

    Louis Vuitton Handbags

    Original Rolex Watches

    1:1 Replica Breitling Watches

    Omega Watches Replica

    Replica Tag Heuer

    A lot of the time when I buy things off websites, I dont have any choice in the courier that the company uses but I try and avoid using Louis Vuitton Handbags if I can. Rolex Air King UK capital to actualize a watch for chase car drivers.The aftereffect is a 1:1 Replica Breitling Watches that has accomplished band status.Omega Watches Replica’s a lot of iconic models are associated with auto racing.Replica Tag Heuer is teaming up by the whole of an institute called Save America’s Clocks.The company kept detailed records for each Original Rolex Watches that has left the factory since 1885.

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. This comment has been removed by the author.