Thursday, November 26, 2009

The Biographer’s Doubt 2..

‘Most biographers have an infantile fixation on their hero/subjects, and want to idealise them and turn them into their fathers.’ - Hermione Lee on why Freud thinks people write biographies.

Was I seeking an ideal father? I have been pondering my relationship to Colenso, this quirky, difficult man, wondering if I have over-invested in resuscitating Colenso’s historical reputation. Why, I wondered, did I feel a companionship with this strange, isolated man? Or does this answer the query? 

Was this search for an alternative father the Freudian basis of my interest in him however? It was a disturbing thought. My own father was nothing like Colenso - in fact I think Colenso would have been a nightmare of a father in some ways - overbearing, impossible, too opinionated, too needy - and too generous. Both his sons - Latimer, the legitimate one and Wiremu - the illegitimate son - both became English gentleman, living on the money William endlessly gave them. He spoiled them. Literally, perhaps. Latimer always strikes me as a rather narrow-hearted man, a shard of a person. Wiremu - well, there is another story there, probably an entire novel....or work of nonfiction. (I understand a Canadian relative, a female academic, is writing a book on Wiremu Colenso, a fascinating enigma of a character.)

So - am I seeking a substitute father? I can’t answer that. What I can say is what I value in William Colenso: that is a hot witness, an agitated voice, an almost impure subject - someone who is not slow to speak, have an opinion. He also saw and thought and wrote at a key time in New Zealand’s history. He changed his opinions over his life time. He was versatile. He was, I suppose, when you get down to it, an eye witness.This for me - a person who loves the smell and density and darkness and strangely shaped corriders and underground tunnels of history - is what I really like about William Colenso. He leads me into the past, shines a torch over things which might have otherwise remained unseen, unknown - even unthought of. 

And finally, his own moral complexity - his ‘fall from grace’ - makes him a good companion. A man uneasy in his own skin is an interesting person, a contemporary person. He was vivid, gabby, opinionated, often wrong, often right. But he was never neutral, cautious, prim. He was an individual. So probably I’m not so much seeking a father as a guide/companion as I walk backwards - or is it forwards? - into the past. 

Oh, and a rather nice daddy wouldn’t hurt....thanks, Mr Freud.


  1. They incorporate high-fashion and the watches are real showstoppers. The narmi watches formed in The japanese and are often sold under the brand name Geneva. These watches have a quartz movement with an amazing stainless hublot replica uk back and trendy ceramic style and lead free silicon plastic connectors. Watch connectors are no longer simply emotions. As the watches have become products, the connectors attended in the hublot replica as well. The Narmi watches have a luxurious attitude and try to make happy the women with their offerings. A striking band can transform the entire look of a plain breitling replica to a fancy one and can modulate a swish outfit for a formal office wear. Most women prefer such watches as they can match with any outfit and that they come in omega replica colors. The Narmi watches will draw people's awareness of you. The long life, unique designs and fashionable look of the Narmi watches is what makes them stand out from all of those other watches. If you are looking for a striking Narmi watch for yourself that fits your finances, omega replica and taste, internet is the best place to look for them.

  2. Switzerland, home to the industry’s Replica watches UK largest trade show, Baselworld.Into that vacuum of innovation stepped a number of independent Replica handbags who had nothing to lose by letting their imaginations run wild. Take the handbagreplica brand Devon, founded five years ago in Los Angeles by Scott Devon, an entrepreneur. Best known for its . Replica Watches avant-garde-looking Tread models, which incorporate interwoven belts and parts supplied by aerospace companies Rolex Daytona .

  3. Latest news headlines from India in Hindi. Check out today’s most recent & up-to-date news coverage, videos & photos at
    latest news in hindi

  4. There are many forms of insects that spread in the house, including bed bugs, cockroaches, fleas, termites, black and snakes, scorpions and many other insects, and through a lot of equipment and pesticides that kill them quickly.
    شركة مكافحة حشرات
    شركة مكافحة النمل الابيض بالخبر
    شركة مكافحة حشرات بالخبر
    شركة رش مبيدات بالخبر